作者简介:WANG Yi(1980-), male, associate professor, research direction: solid propellants.E-mail: wangyi528528@aliyun.com
(1. 中北大学 材料科学与工程学院, 山西 太原 030051; 2. 中北大学 环境与安全工程学院, 山西 太原030051; 3. 南京理工大学 化工学院, 江苏 南京 210094)
(1. School of Materials Science and Engineering, North University of China, Taiyuan 030051, China; 2. School of Environment and Safety Engineering, North University of China, Taiyuan 030051, China; 3. School of Chemical Engineering, Nanjing University of Science and Technology, Nanjing 210094, China)
physical chemistry; ammonium nitrate; AN; PZT; phase transition; thermal decomposition mechanism
DOI: 10.14077/j.issn.1007-7812.201901035
备注
作者简介:WANG Yi(1980-), male, associate professor, research direction: solid propellants.E-mail: wangyi528528@aliyun.com
以5-氨基四氮唑(5-ATZ)为前驱体合成了5,5'-偶氮四唑钾(PZT)。将不同质量比的PZT和硝酸铵(AN)同时溶解在水中,然后将水蒸发,得到了几种“AN+PZT”复合物。用IR和XRD对PZT和“AN+PZT”复合物进行了相应表征。结果 表明,IR图谱证明了所制备PZT的分子结构,并且说明PZT可能为一种水合物; XRD图谱表明,“AN+PZT”是一种多晶复合物; DSC图谱表明,PZT的存在完全抑制了AN在环境温度下的晶体相变,即原料AN在57.1℃下的相变吸热完全消失; 所有“AN+PZT”复合物的热分解峰温与原料AN相比明显降低; 原料AN热分解的最终产物为N2O、HNO3和H2O。与原料AN相比,“0.8AN+0.2PZT”的热分解未生成HNO3,但有NH3作为中间产物生成。推测在AN解离为NH3和HNO3后,HNO3先与PZT发生了反应,而NH3则剩余下来并在更高的温度下被HNO3氧化。由于AN热分解的控制步骤是其解离产物中HNO3的分解,因此PZT的引入在反应机理上促进了AN的热分解。
Potassium 5,5'-azotetrazolate(raw PZT)was synthesized using 5-amino-1H-tetrazol(5-ATZ)as the precursor. By dissolving raw PZT and ammonium nitrate(AN)in water, evaporating the water off, and then “AN+PZT” composites were prepared. IR and XRD analyses were employed to characterize raw PZT and “AN+PZT” composites. Thermal analyses were performed to probe the effect of raw PZT on phase transition and thermolysis of AN. The molecular structure of raw PZT was confirmed by IR spectrum, and results demonstrate that raw PZT is a kind of hydrate. XRD patterns of “AN+PZT” composites reveal that some eutectics generate during the preparation. DSC curves of “AN+PZT” composites disclose that the phase transformation of AN at ambient temperature is entirely inhibited by doping with raw PZT. Peak temperature for decomposition of AN also decrease obviously by doping with raw PZT. The final decomposition products of “0.8AN+0.2PZT” composite are N2O, HNO3 and H2O. By compared “0.8AN+0.2PZT”composite with pure AN, it is found that HNO3 disappear, while NH3 is detected as an intermediate product. It may be because that PZT react with HNO3 firstly after decomposition of AN, and NH3 is oxided by HNO3 at a higher temperature. This promotes thermal decomposition of AN in mechanism since the consumption of HNO3 dominates its thermolysis.
Introduction
Ammonium nitrate(AN)is a low cost and easy available energetic material which is extensively used in industrial explosives [1-3]. In propellants, AN is also a promising oxidizer of which the combustion is of the feature such as free halogen, low temperature, and low signature. However, two factors block the application of AN. Firstly, both energy and combustion performances of AN are much poor. Thus, AN had not been applied as main oxidizer in the propellants of any type of rocket, and it were just slightly used in some formulation of gas generation agents [4-6]. Secondly, phase transformation at ambient temperature is the most fatal defect of AN. We all know that AN exists as five crystal forms, and the phase transformation occurs at 125, 84, 32, and -18℃, respectively. Phase transformation at 32℃ is accompanied by a significant volume expansion which results in crack formation in the propellant grain[7]. The mechanical strength of the AN pills is dependent on the phase transition behavior. Thus, before used, it is indispensable to introduce some phase stabilizer to make phase transformation of AN disappeared. At least, the phase transformation at ambient temperature must be inhibited.
There are dozens of papers that reports how to depress phase transformation of AN. Muller as early as 1899 showed that KNO3 forms solid solution with AN and thereby lower the transition temperature [7]. Other salts, such as Cu(NO3)2, Mg(NO3)2, Zn(NO3)2, MnSO4, Na2B4O7,(NH4)2SO4, NH4Cl, etc, also have effects on inhibition of phase transition of AN[8]. Besides inorganic salts, different metal oxides have been reported to have phase stabilization effect on AN. These include NiO, Al2O3, ZnO, CuO, etc [9-11]. However, it requires more than 10% of these inertia addition to inhibit the crystal transformation of AN, that will result in a substantial penalty on energy performance of AN based formula [12]. Potassium nitrate is the most used energetic phase stabilizer for ammonium nitrate, but its energy performance is too poor to be used in modern propellants. The phase transition of AN at ambient temperature disappears by adding 5.0% potassium dinitramide(KDN), but KDN is too expensive to have a large-scale application[13]. Hence, another energetic potassium salt, i.e. potassium 5,5'-azotetrazolate(PZT), comes into our sight. PZT is a kind of polynitrogen compound, and it belongs to the second generation of high nitrogen energetic materials since its oxygen balance(OBCO2=-33%)is not too low. Its nitrogen content is up to 57.8%, and there are two potassium ions in a PZT molecule. Its potassium content accesses to 32.2% which is higher than that of KDN(w(K)%=26.9%)and is closed to that of KNO3(w(K)%=38.7%). Substantial N—N and N〖FY=,*2〗N bonds exist in PZT molecules and their bond energy are very low, which favors to the energy performance in thermodynamics. Therefore, although no oxidizing group exists in PZT molecules, PZT is still a high energy material when it is combined with an oxidizer like AN. Herein, we disclose the effect of PZT on phase transformation and thermal decomposition of AN, and discuss the mechanism.
1 Experiment
1.1 MaterialsAmmonium nitrate(AN)were purchased from Tianjin Guangfu Chemical Co., Ltd.(Tianjin, China).
1.2 FabricationRaw PZT is prepared with the method mentioned in reference [14]. The next step is to prepare “AN+PZT” composites. Herein, please note that grinding the mixture of AN and PZT without any liquid medium is forbidden because this would cause an exothermic solid reaction between AN and PZT, which produces a lot of gas and it smells like ammonia. In this work, we dissolve both AN and PZT into deionized water together. Then put the aqueous solution into a water bath oven at 70℃. Several days later, the water evaporates off and the mixture is obtained. Several mixtures are prepared, in which the mass fraction of PZT in the mixture are 3%, 5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, and 30%. The obtained samples are marked as “0.97AN+0.03PZT”, “0.95AN+0.05PZT”, “0.9AN+0.1PZT”, “0.85AN+0.15PZT”, “0.8AN+0.2PZT”, and “0.7AN+0.3PZT”, respectively.
1.3 Characterization and analysesMorphology was observed with a field-emission scanning electron microscope(SEM, JEOL JSM-7500). IR analysis was performed on American thermofisher scientific Nicolet 6700 infrared spectrometer(iodine bromide tablet). The phases of the samples were investigated with an X-ray powder diffractometer(XRD, Bruker Advance D8)using Cu K_α radiation at 40kV and 30mA. Thermal analyses were performed on a differential scanning calorimeter(TA Model Q600)at heating rates of 20℃/min(N2 atmosphere, sample mass of approximately 5mg, and Al2O3 crucible). DSC-IR analysis was carried out at heating rates of 10℃/min by using a thermal analyzer system(DSC, Mettler Toledo)coupled with a Fourier transforms infrared spectrometer.
2 Results and Discussion
2.1 Characterization of raw PZTThe IR spectrum of raw PZT is presented in Figure 1. The broad absorption peaks locating at 3378cm-1 and 3269cm-1 relate to the symmetric and anti-symmetric vibration of O—H bond in crystallized water. The peak locating at 1665cm-1 corresponds to stretching vibration of N〖FY=,*2〗N bond and N—N in tetrazole ring. The strong peak locating at 1397cm-1 is ascribed to stretching vibration of C—N bond in tetrazole ring. The peaks locating at 1195, 1148, 1063, and 1026cm-1 are also attributed to stretching vibration of C—N bond in tetrazole ring. The peaks locating at 777cm-1 and 732cm-1 relate to the in-plane and out-plane vibrations of tetrazole ring. These results consist with the molecular structure of PZT hydrate(Figure 2).
2.2 Characterization of “AN+PZT” compositesSEM images of all “AN+PZT” composites are showed in Figure 3.Figure 3(a)presents the micron morphology of “0.97AN+ 0.03PZT”.Its particle size is about 300-500μm and its particle surface is very complicated. It seems that the particle surface of “0.97AN+0.03PZT” is etched, which may be resulted from the evaporation of the solvent. The micron morphologies of other composites are similar as that of “0.97AN+0.03PZT”. XRD patterns of raw PZT, pure AN, and all composites are illustrated in Figure 4. Raw PZT is a kind of crystal. Comparing patterns of composites with patterns of raw PZT and pure AN, we can find that some new phases form. The main diffraction peaks of raw PZT locate at 2θ of 32.6° and 11.1°. In all patterns of “AN+PZT”, the diffraction peak at 2θ of 32.6° still exists. The main diffraction peak of pure AN locate at 2θ of 29.1° and 40.2°. In all patterns of “AN+PZT”, the diffraction peaks at 2θ of 29.1° and 40.2° still exist. This means that all “AN+PZT” composites are polycrystalline of AN and PZT. However, the new peak locating at 2θ of 34.3° also exist in the patterns of all composites samples. This implies that eutectic of PZT and AN forms when the solvent is evaporated off. Each composite is the crystal mixture of raw PZT, pure AN, and the co-crystal.
2.3 Thermal analysisThermal decomposition of raw PZT is investigated by TG/DSC analysis and the result is showed in Figure 5. Figure 5(a)illustrates the DSC trace of raw PZT. A broad endothermic peak locates at 87.5-158.1℃, attributed to the sublimation of crystallized water in PZT molecules with heat absorption of +251.3J/g. A exothermic peak, relating to thermolysis of PZT, locates at 234.3-269.3℃ with heat release of -105.6J/g. Figure 5(b)and Figure 5(c)illustrate the TG/DTG curves of raw PZT. The TG curve indicates that the consumption of the decomposition contains two steps which correspond to the sublimation of crystallized water and decomposition of PZT. In the first consumption step, the mass loss is 15.3%. At elevated temperature, the consumption becomes very steep with mass loss of 48.5%. After that, as increasing of temperature, the mass loss does not change. This means there is still 36.2% material does not decompose and remains as residue. In DTG curve, it is revealed that the rate of the first consumption is very low and the rate of the second consumption is very high. This means the sublimation of crystallized water is a slow process and the decomposition of PZT is a fast process.
After understood thermolysis of raw PZT, we investigate the effect of raw PZT on phase transformation and thermal decomposition of ammonium nitrate, and the results are showed in Figure 6. The data extracted from DSC traces are listed in Table 1.
It indicates that four endothermic peaks exist in DSC trace of pure AN. The peak locating at 57.1℃ is ascribed to the phase transformation at ambient temperature. This is the most headache problem in phase transition of AN, because phase transformation at this point is accompanied by a significant volume expansion which results in crack formation in the propellant grain [7]. Please see from the DSC trace of “0.97AN+0.03PZT”; by doped with 3% raw PZT, the phase transformation peak at ambient temperature disappears. The disappearance also occurs in other DSC traces of the composite samples. This means that the addition of raw PZT effectively inhibited the phase transition of AN at ambient temperature. The phase modification of AN by K+ and resulting changes in the transition temperature have been explained based on the replacement of some of the ammonium ions by potassium ions. The radius of potassium ion is 0.133nm compared with 0.148nm for the ammonium ion and hence, replacement of NH+4 by K+ favors the AN(III)structure. Consequently, a steady fall in the IV-III transition temperature is observed as the replacement of ammonium ions by potassium ions increases. In DSC trace of pure AN, the peak locating at 137.4℃ corresponds to the phase transition of AN(II)to AN(I). Addition of raw PZT shows no inhibition effect on this phase transition. But it is clear that with increasing the content of raw PZT, the temperature of peak B decreases. And when the mass fraction of PZT accesses to 30%, this phase transition also disappears. In DSC trace of pure AN, the peak locating at 173.5℃ corresponds to the melting point of AN. Similar to peak B, the temperature of peak C(the melting point)also decreases as increasing of raw PZT content. In DSC trace of pure AN, the biggest endothermic peak locating at 313.5℃ is attributed to thermal decomposition of AN. Dissociation of NH4NO3(to NH3 and HNO3)is a strong endothermic process, and the heat release from redox reaction of NH3 with HNO3 can not offset the heat absorption of this dissociation. Thus, under the condition of 0.1MPa, the decomposition of AN presents an endothermic process in DSC trace. The addition of raw PZT does not change the endothermic feature of AN decomposition. However, as the content of PZT increasing, the area of the decomposition peak decreases and peak temperature also decreases. This means that addition of raw PZT promotes thermal decomposition temperature of AN.
Note: Tp-t is phase transformation temperature; Tm is the melting point; Td is decomposition temperature.
For further investigating the effect of PZT on thermal decomposition of AN, DSC-IR analyses are performed and the results are illustrated in Figure 7. Figure 7(a)indicates that much gas produce in time lapse of 1182-1629s. The detected signal is very strong. We extract the IR spectra of the gas products at 1182, 1343, 1466, 1532, and 1629s, and show them in Figure 7(b). It indicates that the main decomposition products of pure AN are N2O, HNO3, and H2O. This is accordance with the common mechanism of AN [15]. Firstly, AN dissociates to NH3 and HNO3; and the HNO3 decomposes to ·OH and ·NO2 radicals; and ·OH reacts with NH3 to form ·NH2 and H2O; and then ·NH2 reacts with ·NO2 to produce N2O and H2O(see Eqs.1-4).
NH4NO3→NH3+HNO3+2.18kJ/g(1)
HNO3→·OH+NO2(2)
NH3+·OH→·NH2+H2O(3)
NH2+NO2→[NH2NO2]→N2O+H2O(4)
This is the radical mechanism for thermal decomposition of AN. Please note that, herein, no NH3 gas exists in gas products of pure AN, but many HNO3 gas are detected. This means that the oxidization of NH3 by decomposition products of HNO3 is not the rate-limiting step for thermal decomposition of AN. Thermolysis of AN is dominated by decomposition of HNO3, which has been confirmed in Izato's and Sinditskii's works [16-17]. In this work, the detection of HNO3 also reveals that decomposition of HNO3 is the rate-limiting step for thermolysis of AN. Now, please see Figure 7(c)and 7(d), they illustrate the result of AN doped with 20% raw PZT, i.e. the sample “0.8AN+0.2PZT”. The final decomposition products of “0.8AN+0.2PZT” are N2O and H2O. Comparing with the result of pure AN, we can find no HNO3 exists in decomposition products of “0.8AN+0.2PZT”. This confirms that HNO3 has reacted with something without decomposition. In Figure 7(d), please note that there are many NH3 detected as intermediate product. The NH3 may be produced from dissociation of AN, or from decomposition of raw PZT. In order to disclose this mechanism, the DSC-IR analysis of raw PZT is also performed and the result is showed in Figure 7(e)and 7(f). Figure 7(e)indicates that the decomposition of raw PZT is divided into two steps. Figure 7(f)reveals that the first step corresponds to sublimation of crystallized water and the second step relates to the decomposition of PZT. It is obvious that no NH3 exists in decomposition products of raw PZT. Thus, in Figure 7(f), we speculate that the products(N2O, NO2, CO)are resulted from the reaction of N and C atoms(in PZT)with H2O steam, since there are no oxidizing groups existing in molecules of raw PZT. Herein, the H2O steam acts as the oxidizer. Now, let's go back to decomposition of “0.8AN+0.2PZT” in Figure 7(d). The produced NH3 should be the reminder of dissociation of AN. As abovementioned, AN dissociates to NH3 and HNO3 firstly. It is speculated that the PZT skeletons directly react with HNO3(prior to NH3)to produce N2O and H2O. Hence, the NH3 is detected as an intermediate product. Of course, all NH3 gas eventually reacts with decomposition products of HNO3, since no NH3 is detected in final products of “0.8AN+0.2PZT”. We have known that the rate-limiting step for decomposition of AN is the decomposition of HNO3. Here, it confirms that addition of raw PZT improves the consumption of HNO3, i.e. thermal decomposition of AN is promoted in mechanism.
3 Conclusions
(1)Raw PZT is prepared and its molecular structure is confirmed by IR analysis. Six “AN+PZT” composites are prepared and their micron morphology and crystal phase are probed. Their particle surface is very complicated and some eutectic generate from preparation of the composites. The composites are not single crystal but rather polycrystalline.
(2)Thermal decomposition of raw PZT is investigated by TG/DSC analysis. An endothermic peak and an exothermic peak locate at 122.2℃ and 156.1℃, respectively, which relate to the sublimation of the crystallized water and decomposition of PZT. DSC traces of “AN+PZT” composites reveal that the phase transformation of AN at ambient temperature is entirely inhibited when 3.0%(or more)raw PZT is added into. The decomposition peak of AN also advances by adding raw PZT. DSC-IR analysis discloses that the decomposition products of pure AN are N2O, HNO3, and H2O. The final decomposition products of “0.8AN+0.2PZT” are N2O and H2O; meanwhile, some NH3 gas is detected as intermediate product. It is speculated that PZT reacts with HNO3 directly, and this promotes thermal decomposition of AN.
- [1] FORDHAM S. High Explosives and Propellants [M]. London: Pergamon Press, 1966: 40-41.
- [2]LIU Ling, YUAN Jun-ming, LIU Yu-cun. Shock wave overpressure test and evaluation of TNT equivalent of self-made explosives [J]. Chinese Journal of Explosives & Propellants(Huozhayao Xuebao), 2015, 38(2): 50-53.
- [3]YE Zhi-wen, Lü Chun-xu, LIU Da-bin. Preparation and properties of new high strength emulsion explosive [J]. Chinese Journal of Explosives & Propellants(Huozhayao Xuebao), 2011, 34(6): 41-44.
- [4]KAZUO HASUE, MAKOTO MATSUKAWA. Mixtures of phase-stabilized ammonium nitrate containing 10 wt% potassium nitrate and tetrazoles as gas-generating agents [J]. Science and Technology of Energetic Materials, 2016, 77(3): 98-104.
- [5]KAZUO HASUE, KAZUYA YOSHITAKE. The mixture of the phase stabilized ammonium nitrate containing potassium nitrate and 1HT as the new gas generant composition [J]. Science and Technology of Energetic Materials, 2013, 74(3): 66-72.
- [6]KAZUO HASUE, KAZUYA YOSHITAKE, MAKOTO MATSUKAWA. Mixtures of phase-stabilized ammonium nitrate and tetrazoles as new gas-generating agent compositions [J]. Central European Journal of Energetic Materials, 2016, 13(1): 247-260.
- [7]OOMMEN C, JAIN S R. Ammonium nitrate: a promising rocket propellant oxidizer [J]. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 1999, A67: 253-281.
- [8]KLIMOVA I, KALJUVEE T, TURN L. Interactions of ammonium nitrate with different additives [J]. Journal of Thermal Analysis & Calorimetry, 2011, 105(1): 13-26.
- [9]CHOI C S, PRASK H J, PRINCE E. Phase transition in ammonium nitrate [J]. Journal of Applied Crystallography, 2010, 13(5): 403-409.
- [10]OWENS F J. Electron paramagnetic resonance study of the role of CuO additives in altering phase transition behavior of ammonium nitrate [J]. Journal of Applied Physics, 1982, 53(1): 368-371.
- [11]HAMILTON B K. Phase-stabilized ammonium nitrate: US,US6872265B2 [P]. 2005.
- [12]VARGEESE A A, MIJA S J, MURALIDHARAN K. Effect of copper oxide, titanium dioxide, and lithium fluoride on the thermal behavior and decomposition kinetics of ammonium nitrate [J]. Journal of Energetic Materials, 2014, 32(3): 146-161.
- [13]KUMAR P, JOSHI P. Thermal decomposition and kinetics studies of AN, KDN and their mixtures with and without catalysts [J]. Central European Journal of Energetic Materials, 2017, 14(1): 184-200.
- [14]CHEN Bin, WANG Qiong-lin, LI Yue-ping. Synthesis and characterization of potassium 5,5'-azotetrazolate and its effect on reducing muzzle flame and smoke [J].Chinese Journal of Energetic Materials, 2014, 22(4): 478-481.
- [15]CHATURVEDI S, DAVE P N. Review on thermal decomposition of ammonium nitrate [J]. Journal of Energetic Materials, 2013, 31: 1-26.
- [16]YU-ICHIRO IZATO, ATSUMI MIYAKE. Thermal decomposition mechanism of ammonium nitrate and potassium chloride mixtures [J]. Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry, 2015, 121(1): 287-294.